Manual vs. Power Mobility Devices: Which is Best?

Manual vs. Power Mobility Devices: Which is Best?

Deciding to use a mobility device can bring up many feelings. You or your loved ones might feel frustrated, worried, or sad about changes in how you move around. This is normal. Asking for help and using a mobility device shows strength. It’s a good way to take care of yourself and stay as independent as possible.

Mobility devices can improve your quality of life and help you keep your dignity. Choosing the right device is an important step toward feeling more comfortable, safe, and independent. You and your loved ones deserve comfort and confidence.

This article will help you understand the difference between manual and power mobility devices so you can choose the best option for your mobility needs and lifestyle.

Understanding Mobility Devices

When picking a mobility device, you’ll want to think about whether you want a manual (pushed by hand) or a powered (battery-operated) device. Here is a simple explanation:

What Are Manual Mobility Devices?

These include wheelchairs you push yourself or someone else pushes for you, as well as rollators, walkers, and canes. They require some effort from you or a caregiver.

Who Can Benefit?

  • People with good arm strength or some ability to walk.
  • Manual wheelchairs are great if you can push yourself or have someone to help.
  • Rollators and walkers are best for those who can walk but need extra balance and support.
  • Canes help when standing up, sitting down, or walking short distances.

Woman using UPWalker Premium Lite in living room next to man reading on couch

When to Consider Power Devices

Powered mobility devices are a helpful option for people who need extra support to move around easily and comfortably. These include electric wheelchairs, power chairs, and mobility scooters. They’re designed to help you get around with less physical effort than manual devices.

How Do They Work?

Powered devices run on batteries and are controlled by a joystick, buttons, or other easy-to-use controls.

  • You don’t need much arm or hand strength to operate them.
  • They are great for use both at home and out in the community.

Who Can Benefit?

  • People who have limited strength, stamina, or range of motion.
  • Those who cannot walk long distances or who get tired easily.
  • Individuals who have trouble pushing a manual wheelchair.

Power mobility devices make it easier to stay independent, safe, and connected with others. They allow you to go farther, move comfortably, and take part in daily activities with greater confidence.

Image of a man in a chair and a woman in an Air Elite sitting at an outdoor table

How to Compare Your Manual vs. Power Mobility Options

There are several things to consider when determining whether you need a manual or power mobility device. Some people choose to use a combination of the two. For example, many individuals who use power chairs also use walkers in their homes.

Strength and Range of Motion

Assess your strength, endurance, and joint mobility, considering the risk of overuse injuries and any posture support needed. Prolonged manual wheelchair use can lead to overuse injuries. Powered devices can reduce this risk and often provide better posture support.

Manual devices will require some strength and stamina, while powered devices are better for users with limited strength or endurance. You’ll need shoulder and arm mobility to use a manual wheelchair and a certain level of hip and knee mobility for using a rollator.

Lifestyle and Daily Activities

Think about your daily routines, hobbies, and social activities. Manual devices such as rollators work well for those who want to maintain physical fitness. They’re also suitable for traveling a short distance or within a smaller area. Powered devices offer ease for longer outings, busy days, and travel when you need to cover more ground or stick to a tight schedule.

You may want a powered device such as a scooter or power chair for longer outings and travel, while a rollator might be the perfect fit for short walks through the neighborhood.

Powered devices typically have higher upfront costs and may require more maintenance and replacements for items such as batteries or electrical parts.

Environment

Powered devices are better suited for hilly areas and challenging terrain, while manual devices are easier to maneuver indoors or in tight spaces.

How will each device you’re considering fit into your lifestyle and living environment? Consider whether you’ll be using the device indoors, outdoors, or both. What kind of terrain will you be on most often?  For example, you might be using a rollator in a carpeted apartment or driving a mobility scooter through a hilly suburban neighborhood.

Will you be able to easily travel with the device? What are your space constraints in your home, vehicle, or public transportation?

Independence and Control

Both manual and power mobility devices support independence. Some users prefer the control of a manual device. Others like the freedom a powered device offers. It can time to adjust to using a mobility device, but users frequently share stories of pride and self-worth, such as this review from Deborah J.:

This walker is amazing! I recently purchased my walker because I can walk short distances well, but long distances are a challenge. My family and I just returned from a trip to Outer Banks, NC. While there, I went to Kill Devil Hills and visited the Wright Bros. museum and monument. I, of course, took my UPWalker, too. The monument is a 2.7 mile loop with an elevation of 95 feet. Pretty steep! But, with my walker, I walked the entire loop!!!!!!! I could not have walked any of it if I had not had my walker. I was thrilled that I could do that walk and proud that I did it!!  Anyone with a challenge in walking needs to seriously look at purchasing one of the UPWalkers. Around home I walk with my husband who is an avid walker. I can now keep up with him!!!  Love my walker!!!!! Thank you. 

Involving Caregivers and Loved Ones

Talking about changes in mobility can be challenging. Have open and respectful conversations with your loved ones and caregivers about what you need and your preferences. Caregivers can provide support as needed with the ultimate goal of fostering your independence. Be empathetic, patient, and practice active listening when discussing mobility challenges.

Get Professional Guidance

Your healthcare provider can help you assess your mobility and lifestyle to determine the best fit for you. You can also check out a local mobility store to get a proper fitting to prevent discomfort and overuse injuries.

Tips for a Smooth Transition

Adjusting to a new mobility device can take time. Here are some helpful tips to make the change easier and more comfortable:

  • Take it Slow: Give yourself time to get used to your new device. Practice using it indoors first, then gradually venture outside.
  • Ask for Help: Don’t hesitate to ask family, friends, or healthcare professionals for assistance or advice.
  • Keep Active: Find activities you enjoy that you can do safely with your device, like short walks, gardening, or gentle exercises.
  • Stay Connected: Spend time with friends and family. Socializing can boost your mood and keep you motivated.
  • Stay Positive: It’s normal to feel frustrated at times. Celebrate small victories like learning to navigate a new route or using your device independently.
  • Maintain Your Equipment: Regularly check your device for any issues and keep it clean and well-maintained to avoid problems.

Funding and Payment Options for Mobility Devices

Finding the right mobility device is an important step toward greater comfort, freedom, and joy in daily life. There are many ways to make it more affordable.

Medicare, Medicaid, and veterans’ benefits often help cover the cost of medically necessary equipment, and private insurance may provide support with the right documentation. If you have a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Flexible Spending Account (FSA), you can use these to pay for a device with pre-tax dollars. Local charities and nonprofit organizations also offer grants or low-cost equipment for those who qualify, helping to make access possible for everyone.

If paying all at once feels overwhelming, remember that many suppliers offer installment plans, rental options, or lease-to-own programs. You’re not alone! Many people and organizations are ready to help you explore your options and find what works best for your needs.

Journey Health & Lifestyle offers pay over time payment plans with Bread Pay, as well as the option to pay using HSA/FSA funds. Our friendly product specialists can provide more information about these options.

Mobility Resources and Support

You don’t have to go on this journey alone. There are many people and organizations ready to help:

  • Local Support Groups: Look for mobility or senior support groups in your community. They meet regularly and offer friendship, advice, and encouragement.
  • Easterseals: Provides resources and information on mobility devices.
  • National Institute on Aging (NIA): Offers guidance on aging and mobility.
  • Eldercare Locator: 1-800-677-1116 – Connects older adults with local services.
  • Online Communities: Join forums where you can share experiences and get advice.
  • Lifestyle Specialists: Occupational therapists and physical therapists can help you learn how to use your device safely and make your home more accessible.

Moving Forward Together

Every person’s journey with a mobility device is unique. It’s important to treat yourself with kindness and patience as you adjust.

Remember, reaching out for support is a sign of courage and strength. You don’t have to face changes in mobility alone. Celebrate each step you take toward greater freedom and comfort, no matter how small.

Together, you can find new ways to live fully, stay connected to others, and enjoy your independence.

Choosing the right mobility device is a personal decision that should be carefully considered, ideally in consultation with healthcare professionals. For more information, call 1-888-404-1724 to speak with a mobility product specialist.

Related Articles